CHAP. 34. (19.)—FISHES WHICH HAVE A VOICE .— FISHES WITHOUT GILLS.
Arcadia produces a wonder in its fish called exocœtus,[1] from
the fact that it comes ashore to sleep. In the neighbourhood
of the river Clitorius,[2] this fish is said to be gifted with powers
of speech, and to have no gills;[3] by some writers it is called
the adonis.
1. )Apo\ to=n e)/cw koita=n, "from its sleeping out of the water." This
fish is also mentioned by Theophrastus, in his Fragment on the "Fish that
live on dry land;" by Clearchus the Peripatetic, as quoted by Athenæus,
B. viii.; Oppian, in his Halieutics, B. i. 1. 158; and. Ælian, Hist. Anim.
B. ix. c. 36. The fish, however, mentioned by all these authorities, is a sea-
fish, while that of Pliny, being found in Arcadia, must, of necessity, be a river
fish. The proper name of the fish here mentioned by him was poikili/as,
Hardouin says, so called from the variety of its colours. Cuvier says, that
the fish here mentioned is not the Exocœtus of Linnæus, which is one of
the flying fish, but is clearly of opinion that it is one of the genus Blennius, or Gobio, that is alluded to; for these small fish are often to be found
left on the shore when the waters retire, and have the property of being
able to remain alive for a considerable time without water.
2. In the river Aroanius, which falls into the Clitorius. Pausanias
mentions this story, but adds, that he never could hear the fish, although
he often went there to listen, Mnaseas of Patræ, an author quoted by
Athenæus, B. viii., also mentions these vocal fishes.
3. Cuvier understands this to mean only, that the openings of the gills
are remarkably small: for, as he says, there is no fish whatever without
gills. It is very possible, however, that Pliny may have mistranslated a
passage found in Athenæus, and quoted from Clearchus the Peripatetic,
in which he says that some fish have a voice, and yet have no throat,
bro/gxon; which may have, possibly, been mistaken by our author for
bra/gxia, "gills."